Artwork by Allison Horst
Pre-class Prep
NA
Lecture Materials
There is no lecture this week!
Discussion Materials
Pre-discussion Prep
HW #3 has you working on your visualizations for your final project (HW #4). Please plan to bring the following to discussion:
- one of your three visualizations (i.e. one of the three required viz for option 1, or one of the three viz that will make up your infographic for option 2)
- the question that you’re trying to answer with your visualization
Add your visualization and your question to the appropriate Google slide deck (each slide is labeled with a name) before section begins:
The viz you bring should meet the HW #3 requirements (see the section that begins with “Mock up your visualizations using code…”) – this should be a well-constructed, carefully thought-through and polished plot (any one of the panels in the Hollywood Age Gaps visualization that you saw in discussion last week is a great example of the level of “polish” we’d expect to see). You should be prepared to discuss your design choices and receive constructive feedback from your peers.
How to give / receive feedback
Giving, receiving and implementing feedback is an important part of any creative process (including building data visualizations!). There are two “levels” of feedback:
- high-level: where the focus is on whether a data visualization is accurate, relevant and understandable for the intended audience
- detail-oriented: where the focus is on aesthetics choices (e.g. colors, typefaces, layout, themes, white space, etc.) and how those choices help to enhance / tell the story This week, you should focus largely on providing high-level feedback (though suggestions on how to tweak the details of a visualization are welcome).
For giving feedback:
- focus on the strengths / weakness of the visualization itself, not the person who created it
- balance positive and negative feedback, and start with the positives!
- stay objective when suggesting improvements (e.g. “This part might benefit from some clarity…”)
- suggest actionable solutions and / or alternatives, rather than only problems or criticisms
For receiving feedback:
- receiving feedback can be stressful – this is a very normal feeling!
- listen carefully without disrupting / defending yourself
- take notes, ask questions, and thank your feedback giver(s)
- evaluate your feedback objectively to decide what to keep / reject / modify
For applying feedback:
- prioritize feedback based on relevance, importance, and feasibility
- create a plan and a timeline to implement
- critically evaluate / compare your before and after versions
- seek new feedback!
Supplementary resources
- Design and Redesign, by Fernanda Viégas & Martin Wattenberg
- A Better Path Toward Criticizing Data Visualizations, by Colin Mcnamara
- The beauty of data visualization, a TED Talk by David McCandless (founder of information is beautiful) – this is a fun watch!
Assignment Reminders
Assignment Type | Assignment Title | Date Assigned | Date Due |
---|---|---|---|
HW | Homework Assignment #3 | Mon 02/12/2024 | Sat 02/24/2024, 11:59pm PT |